|Research Paper 63|
Understanding the Economic Value of Legal Covenants in Investment Contracts:
A Real-Options Approach to Venture Equity Contracts
COSSIN - HEC-University of Lausanne, FAME and IMD
SALIASI - HEC-University of Lausanne and FAME
Click here to download a .pdf of this paper
early-stage high-technology growth-oriented companies is a challenge to current valuation methodologies.
This inability to come up with robust point estimates of value should not and does not lead to a breakdown
of market liquidity: instead, efforts are redirected towards the design of investment contracts which
materially skew the distribution of payoffs in favor of the venture investors. In effect, limitations
in valuation abilities are addressed by designing the investment contracts as baskets of real options
instead of linear payoff functions. This paper investigates four common features (covenants) of venture
capital investment contracts from a real option perspective, using both analytical solutions and numerical
analysis to draw inferences for a better understanding of contract features. The impact of the concept
for pricing issues, valuation negotiation and for contract design are considered. It is shown for example
how “contingent pre-contracting” for follow-up rounds is theoretically a better proposition than the
simple “rights of first refusal” commonly found in many contracts. We also provide for results (such
as timing of investments, length of rounds, choices of liquidation levels, conversion levels) that take
into account full interaction of the different features considered. We document some complex facts,
such as the concavity of the VC contract value depending on the amount invested at the different stages,
the actual share impact of the most common antidilution feature, some endogenous motivation for early
VC exits from otherwise performing companies, and stress overall the importance of a full analysis for
efficient contract negociation and understanding.
SFI Public Lecture with Nobel Prize Winner Prof. Thomas J. Sargent, Zurich
Topic: The US then, Europe now
SFI Lunch & Learn Informationsveranstaltung, Zürich
SFI - SRA Event with David Cole, Zurich
Topic: Risk Culture. A Continuing Journey.
SFI - ETH Lunch Seminar with Prof. Andrew W. Lo, Zurich
Topic: Evolutionary Foundations of Economic Behavior, Bounded Rationality, and Intelligence
SFI Evening Seminar with Prof. Andrew W. Lo, Zurich
Topic: Can Financial Engineering Cure Cancer? New Approaches to Funding Biomedical Innovation.
Swiss Finance Institute and zeb.rolfes.schierenbeck.associates launch the first Swiss Asset Management Survey.
Swiss Finance Institute publishes its second White Paper on "Will investment banking survive? Regulatory changes and technological advances are altering the investment banking landscape" written by SFI Prof. Semyon Malamud.
English version, German version, French version, Italian version
More press releases...
SFI in the news
NZZ: "Hohe Risiken einer grossen SNB-Bilanz"
Agefi: "Les taux négatifs aident à affaiblir le franc"
Articles about Jean-Pierre Danthine's speech on "Swiss monetary policy facts... and fiction" at the SFI Evening Seminar (20.05.2015)
Privat: "Und wenn sich Herr Draghi irrt?"
Article by SFI Adjunct Prof. Erwin Heri on the European Central Bank expansionist monetary policy (16.05.2015)
Finanz und Wirtschaft: "Digitales Swiss Banking"
Article by SFI Adjunct Prof. Teodoro Cocca on social media and Fintech and whether they will revolutionize banking (29.04.2015)
NZZ: "Dominante Rolle von CS, UBS und ZKB"
Article on SFI Prof. Semyon Malamud's white paper on "The Future of Investment Banking" (17.04.2015)
More press coverage...